Tuesday, September 2, 2025

1978 NFL Predictions

The new NFL season kicks off tonight, Saturday, Sept. 2, 1978, with the New York Giants playing the Buccaneers in Tampa, Florida. However, that game will not be on TV; instead, Channel 3 is showing this:


1978 me is about as excited as I can possibly be to put the game on and then splay out my football cards on the living-room floor and get them all sorted out for the new season. Here's how I project things to go, by the way:






This, of course, would be a crushing result for us Miami Dolphins fans, but the numbers of my super-secret rating system are what the numbers of my super-secret rating system are. And the numbers are significantly worse for the Dolphins after A.J. Duhe was sidelined by injury early and Bob Griese late during the preseason. 

The NFL slimmed from six to four exhibition games this summer, but injuries have remained a huge part of the story of the leadup to the regular season. In addition to Miami defensive end Duhe and quarterback Griese, injuries apparently have shelved for one or multiple weeks of the regular season Baltimore Colts quarterback Bert Jones, New England Patriots wide receiver Darryl Stingley, Cincinnati Bengals qurterback Ken Anderson, Giants defensive lineman Troy Archer and Chicago Bears cornerback Allan Ellis. These players projected among the league's very best players at their positions. How quickly they return to action and which others are sidelined when will have giant influence on how things actually go on the field, and neither of those influences is factored into my predictions.

Nor, really, is the possible impact of rookies. Houston Oilers running back Earl Campbell looks amazing. New Orleans Saints wide receiver Wes Chandler, San Diego Chargers wide receiver John Jefferson, Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Doug Williams, Denver Broncos nose tackle Don Latimer and Dallas Cowboys tight end/fullback Todd Christensen also have looked great. Kansas City Chiefs defensive linemen Art Still and Sylvester Hicks, San Francisco 49ers tight end Ken MacAfee, Cincinnati defensive end Ross Browner, Detroit Lions safety Luther Bradley, Atlanta Falcons tackle Mike Kenn, Green Bay Packers linebacker John Anderson and Los Angeles Rams kicker Frank Corral appear as though have wide-open immediate opportunities to contribute to their team's fortunes in big ways.

And then there's coaching. I came up with my super-secret rating system only last season, and I haven't quite figured out how to suss out the specific impact of coaching. Of course, it is tremendous. The Dolphins (10-4), Cleveland Browns (6-8), Broncos (12-2), Washington (9-5) and Falcons (7-7) all fared significantly better than I projected them to in NFL77, and I can't help but believe that head coaches Don Shula, Forrest Gregg, Red Miller, George Allen and Leeman Bennett (of Paducah!) were the primary reasons why. 

Better projecting the likely impact of rookies and measuring that of head coaches are this season's major points of emphasis in refining my super-secret rating system.

Interestingly, neither Gregg nor Allen is back with the team he coached in NFL77, and now neither is employed by any team as NFL78 dawns. Gregg took an assistant-coaching job with the Chargers but then decided his heart wasn't in it. Allen was hired away from Washington by the Rams, but then Carroll Rosenbloom decided his head hadn't been in it. "I made a serious error in judgment," he was quoted as saying after Los Angeles's 0-2 start in the preseason. He fired Allen and promoted assistant coach Ray Malavasi to guide the Rams.

But Shula is back in Miami, which gives me hope that the Dolphins will outperform my expectations. And Bennett is back in Atlanta, which I bet keeps the sports desks at The Paducah Sun (no longer the Sun-Democrat) and Channel 6 dialed in all autumn. And Miller is back with Denver, which I think is going to win the whole thing. 

For most of the preseason, my super-secret rating system actually had the Broncos going undefeated in NFL78. But then the Oakland Raiders picked up one of the league's top defensive players, cornerback Monte Jackson, from the Rams, and, in perhaps the only moment in my entire actual life that I was happy about the good fortune of the Raiders, that acquisition tipped Week 14 Broncos-at-Raiders in favor of the home team. ("Phew!" 2025 and 1978 me simultaneously exclaimed in honor of the 1972 Dolphins.)

Thank you, Matthew, for inspiring me to work through this fun project over the last several weeks, and thank you, GoHeath, for sustaining my enthusiasm throughout the period. Let's go NFL of every year, indeed!

Monday, September 1, 2025

Thirty-Two Franchises: Baltimore Ravens

Have participated in the NFL since the 1996 Season.

All-Time Record:  268-199-1 (.574)

The Baltimore Colts played 423 regular season games in the NFL.  The Baltimore Ravens have played 468.  If the two Baltimore franchises were combined, then their history looks like this:

1953-1983:  222-194-7 (.534)
1996-2024:  268-199-1 (.574)
Total:  490-393-8 (.554)

So the Baltimore teams, combined, have a better winning percentage than any Franchise other than Dallas and Green Bay.  Baltimore also has three Super Bowl Titles -- despite not having a team from 1984 through 1995.  Lots of towns take pride in their "Blue Collar" football culture, but most of them have not been able to keep pace with Charm City.

Super Bowl Record:  2-0 (XXXV, XLVII) (2000, 2012)

Top Passer:  Joe Flacco (38,245 yds)
Top Rusher:  Jamal Lewis (7,801 yds)
Top Receiver:  Derrick Mason (5,777 yds)
Top Coach:  John Harbaugh (172 wins)

Top All-Time Player Based on Approximate Value:  Ray Lewis (AV of 224)

And that's all.  Let's go 2025-26 NFL!

Thirty-Two Franchises: Dallas Cowboys

Have participated in the NFL since the 1960 season.

All-Time Record:  569-423-6 (.574)

Super Bowl Record:  5-3 (VI, XII, XXVII, XXVIII, XXX) (1971, 1977, 1992, 1993, 1995)

Here are the three eras of Cowboy football:

1960-1988:  Tom Landry Era:  250-162-6 (.607) (Two Super Bowl Championships)
1989-1993:  Jimmy Johnson Era:  44-36-0 (.550) (Two Super Bowl Championships)
1994-2025:  Jerry Jones Era:  275-225-0 (.550) (One Super Bowl Championship)

The Cowboys have not played for the NFC title since the 1995 Season.

Top Passer:  Tony Romo (34,183 yds)
Top Rusher:  Emmitt Smith (17,162 yds)
Top Receiver:  Jason Witten (12,977 yds)
Top Coach:  Tom Landry (250 wins)

Top All-Time Player Based on Approximate Value:  Emmitt Smith (AV of 162)

Emmitt Smith has the highest AV of any running back.

Thirty-Two Franchises: Green Bay Packers

Have participated in the NFL since the 1921 Season.

All-Time Record:  810-604-38 (.572)

The Packers have the best record of all the NFL teams that were in the League before World War II began:

Packers:  .572
Bears:  .553
Steelers:  .538
Giants:  .522
Rams:  .507
Eagles:  .500
Washington:  .497
Lions:  .461
Cardinals:  .422

Super Bowl Record:  4-1 (I, II, XXXI, XLV) (1966, 1967, 1996, 2010)

Remarkably, for all their success, the Packers have been to the Super Bowl only once since 1997.  During that time, the Packers lost the NFC title game in the following seasons:  2007, 2014, 2016, 2019, and 2020.

Top Passer:  Brett Favre (61,655 yds)
Top Rusher:  Ahman Green (8,322 yds)
Top Receiver:  Donald Driver (10,137 yds)
Top Coach:  Curly Lambeau (209 wins)

Interestingly, the Packers won five NFL titles between 1961 and 1967, but no one from those teams is represented on the list above.  

Top All-Time Player Based on Approximate Value:  Aaron Rodgers (AV of 231)

Rodgers's regular season record as a starter at Green Bay:  153-87-1 (.637)
Favre's regular season record as a starter at Green Bay:  160-93-0 (.632)
Bart Starr's regular season record as a starter at Green Bay:  94-57-6 (.618)

Vince Lombardi's regular season record at Green Bay was 95-36-5 (.717).  Lombardi's record in the playoffs at Green Bay:  9-1.

NFL Week One and Survivor Pick

The NFL Season starts on Thursday.  Here is ESPN's first Top Ten power ranking for the year:

1.  Baltimore:  0-0
2.  Buffalo:  0-0
3.  Detroit:  0-0
4.  Philadelphia:  0-0
5.  Kansas City:  0-0
6.  Tampa Bay:  0-0
7.  Denver:  0-0
8.  Los Angeles:  0-0
9.  Minnesota:  0-0
10.  Green Bay: 0-0

Washington begins the season at number 11.  Miami begins at 22.

The NFL always likes to give us some good matchups for Week One, and sure enough we have a rare 1 v. 2 matchup, with the Ravens going to Buffalo for a matchup with the Bills on Sunday Night.  Also, Number-10 Green Bay will host Number-3 Detroit on Sunday Afternoon.  So the season will be off to a fun start.

Once again, we are going to try our hand at Survivor Pool.  Last year, the Bengals let us down in Week One, losing to a dreadful Patriots team at home.  We can take some consolation from the fact that this lost ultimately cost Cincinnati a spot in the playoffs, but we would like to do better.

Week One is always tough for Survivor Pools, because the League generally likes to match up good teams with good teams, and it also schedules a number of rivalry games.  For example, I would never want to use Giants/Washington, Philly/Dallas, San Diego/Kansas City, or Cincinnati/Cleveland -- to pick a few examples from Week One -- as a Survivor choice.  In general, you want a team that's (1) favored, (2) at home, (3) against a non-divisional opponent.  Also, you'd like to avoid special night games.

With this background, I'm going with Denver over Tennessee.  This game will be played on Sunday afternoon, in Denver, and the Broncos are favored by eight points.  I believe Denver will win this game and be tough all year.  So I'm taking the Broncos.